User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Interpreting the Polls
Page:
 
nano4288
offline
Link
 
There are a lot of votes for playing teams at their own level no matter what region they are in, but if you add up all of the other votes you get 4335 who want to play at own level no matter what region they are in, and 4456 who didn't vote that way. So if Bort makes it that we all play in different regions then thats pissing off slightly more than 50% of the game's population. If he takes the option to have teams play at their own level within regions, then he's appeasing the 4335 who don't care where they play (note: they didn't say that they vote to NOT play in their region, they simply voted they don't care where they play meaning if they stay in their own region they don't care) as well as the 1854 people who have so far voted that they want a shuffle but only within regions. That means that if Bort decides on a shuffle within regions, it will be making 6189/8791 (70%) of voters happy... thats most likely the correct choice for Bort to make.

Just wanted to point this out, because a lot of people so far seem to be freaking out and assuming that since over 4,000 people voted that they wanted a shuffle and didn't care which region, and not even 2,000 voted that they want to remain in their own region, that the first group would win. Not only would be it a bad decision for Bort to appease that group simply because they had the most votes (this would be comporable to a minority government... most votes out of any option but still not 50%+1), but it would in fact be a good decision for Bort to take the second option which would appease both the 4000+ and the ~2000 who want some parity in terms of level of teams.
 
demonicangel
offline
Link
 
Its all good, if they make sure each league is competitive. If leagues are still forced to have to play games they dont have to game plan against, then its pointless.
 
Jim Mora
offline
Link
 
I still think tearing apart the community of some of these leagues is a horrible idea. Increased promotion might work, it's not ideal, but it could be the lesser of two evils. As you've seen, Canada AA2 is a great community - it would be a shame to see those teams flung to far reaches of the globe, and I'm sure it will lead to increased gutting.
Last edited Sep 24, 2008 14:30:15
 
demonicangel
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jim Mora
I still think tearing apart the community of some of these leagues is a horrible idea. Increased promotion might work, it's not ideal, but it could be the lesser of two evils. As you've seen, Canada AA2 is a great community - it would be a shame to see those teams flung to far reaches of the globe, and I'm sure it will lead to increased gutting.


For leagues like EEP that would take a good 4 seasons to get the kinks out. By then, players are retiring, and the mess starts all over again.
 
Jim Mora
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by demonicangel
Originally posted by Jim Mora

I still think tearing apart the community of some of these leagues is a horrible idea. Increased promotion might work, it's not ideal, but it could be the lesser of two evils. As you've seen, Canada AA2 is a great community - it would be a shame to see those teams flung to far reaches of the globe, and I'm sure it will lead to increased gutting.


For leagues like EEP that would take a good 4 seasons to get the kinks out. By then, players are retiring, and the mess starts all over again.


So how does increased promotion/relegation within the conference not solve that? The community of EE-AAA1 and EE-AAA2 are mostly preserved, rivalries still kept intact, etc. instead of random teams being sent to random conferences.
 
1VBChaos
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by nano4288
There are a lot of votes for playing teams at their own level no matter what region they are in, but if you add up all of the other votes you get 4335 who want to play at own level no matter what region they are in, and 4456 who didn't vote that way. So if Bort makes it that we all play in different regions then thats pissing off slightly more than 50% of the game's population. If he takes the option to have teams play at their own level within regions, then he's appeasing the 4335 who don't care where they play (note: they didn't say that they vote to NOT play in their region, they simply voted they don't care where they play meaning if they stay in their own region they don't care) as well as the 1854 people who have so far voted that they want a shuffle but only within regions. That means that if Bort decides on a shuffle within regions, it will be making 6189/8791 (70%) of voters happy... thats most likely the correct choice for Bort to make.

Just wanted to point this out, because a lot of people so far seem to be freaking out and assuming that since over 4,000 people voted that they wanted a shuffle and didn't care which region, and not even 2,000 voted that they want to remain in their own region, that the first group would win. Not only would be it a bad decision for Bort to appease that group simply because they had the most votes (this would be comporable to a minority government... most votes out of any option but still not 50%+1), but it would in fact be a good decision for Bort to take the second option which would appease both the 4000+ and the ~2000 who want some parity in terms of level of teams.


LOL - talk about massaging figures.

I'm getting rather tired of hearing people try to counter the pending result of the poll by spouting shit about majorities and governments.

The fact is, more people have chosen option 1 than any other option. Fine, all the other options combined may be slightly more than 50%, but that doesn't alter the fact that option one ON IT'S OWN is tht most popular choice.

How many more analogies need making about this??

If I gave you a choice of 4 colours to pick as your favourite, and 40% of people picked red, yet 20% of people each picked green, blue and yellow - it does not change the fact that red is the most popular choice.

If you want my opinion, then I think no matter how the vote goes, the final decision will be made to cater for the minority of alpha testers, mods and sundry arse kissers and hangers on in the Pro leagues who just want to keep their monopoly on this game.

The rest of us are just here to provide those 'got here first' teams with someone to beat - and Bort and Co with an income.

 
Link
 
I think Bort set up the poll to fail. He has three options voting for the current symptoms of gutting to get fixed and one for the symptoms to not get fixed. Why? That, and the number of choices guarantees a no majority winner.

Given four choice, I think a single choice having 47% or whatever it's got now is pretty damned good. Bort however never stated if he was going to exhaust the choices or pick a winner by plurality or what. We have no idea what Bort is going to do with the poll.
 
Sarg01
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jim Mora


So how does increased promotion/relegation within the conference not solve that? The community of EE-AAA1 and EE-AAA2 are mostly preserved, rivalries still kept intact, etc. instead of random teams being sent to random conferences.


I'm fairly certain EE AAA #1 (my league) would be thrilled to see 6 up and 12 down. There's a clear upper tier in each conference of 4-5 teams (season 1 teams with rosters that all boost), a mid tier of 4-5 teams (season 2 teams with mostly boosters, but a few not) and a lower tier (everyone gutted season 3 or later) who get slaughtered by everyone in the mid tier.
Last edited Sep 24, 2008 14:48:23
 
demonicangel
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by GMathiasf

Restructuring the entire game is a terrible idea. The fact that it's winning in the polls speaks volumes about the shallowness of thinking of the average GLBer.


Good thing we aren't using the results as the final decision, eh? I don't really want to do that either for the most part, but I wanted to see the stance of the general customer anyway. If enough people are gung ho for something, we'll consider it, but really this is just a test of where the minds of the customers are at, to help us make decisions on some ideas we've already had.


Page 10 if the poll debate thread.
 
1VBChaos
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by demonicangel
Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by GMathiasf


Restructuring the entire game is a terrible idea. The fact that it's winning in the polls speaks volumes about the shallowness of thinking of the average GLBer.


Good thing we aren't using the results as the final decision, eh? I don't really want to do that either for the most part, but I wanted to see the stance of the general customer anyway. If enough people are gung ho for something, we'll pretend to consider it, but really this is just something we thought we'd try to buy ourselves a bit of time and make it look like we give a shit what you lot actually think.


Page 10 if the poll debate thread.


Fixed
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by 1VBChaos
Originally posted by demonicangel

Originally posted by Bort


Originally posted by GMathiasf



Restructuring the entire game is a terrible idea. The fact that it's winning in the polls speaks volumes about the shallowness of thinking of the average GLBer.


Good thing we aren't using the results as the final decision, eh? I don't really want to do that either for the most part, but I wanted to see the stance of the general customer anyway. If enough people are gung ho for something, we'll pretend to consider it, but really this is just something we thought we'd try to buy ourselves a bit of time and make it look like we give a shit what you lot actually think.


Page 10 if the poll debate thread.


Fixed


You have got to be one of the most pessimistic people I have ever met online, and that is saying a lot. I say what I mean. If you don't believe it and think there is some vast conspiracy to make alpha testers win, then go ahead believing it because no one will change your mind, but there really isn't. I could care less who wins and who loses, as long as they play the game straight.
 
FairForever
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by 1VBChaos

Originally posted by demonicangel


Originally posted by Bort



Originally posted by GMathiasf




Restructuring the entire game is a terrible idea. The fact that it's winning in the polls speaks volumes about the shallowness of thinking of the average GLBer.


Good thing we aren't using the results as the final decision, eh? I don't really want to do that either for the most part, but I wanted to see the stance of the general customer anyway. If enough people are gung ho for something, we'll pretend to consider it, but really this is just something we thought we'd try to buy ourselves a bit of time and make it look like we give a shit what you lot actually think.


Page 10 if the poll debate thread.


Fixed


You have got to be one of the most pessimistic people I have ever met online, and that is saying a lot. I say what I mean. If you don't believe it and think there is some vast conspiracy to make alpha testers win, then go ahead believing it because no one will change your mind, but there really isn't. I could care less who wins and who loses, as long as they play the game straight.


Thanks for the 20k FP bonus at the beginning of the season for being an alpha tester, Bort.


 
mzsleeper02
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
I could care less who wins and who loses, as long as they play the game straight.


Wow, so all those things you whispered to me were lies? Oh, how could you. You horrible balloon man.
 
Caledric
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by nano4288
Waaaaaah! the option I picked is losing.


 
Koncorde
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
I could care less who wins and who loses, as long as they play the game straight.


[Sad]"Couldn't".[/Sad]

If possible, I'd like to stay with some of the sides in the current division - and banish the rest. Though currently I think a complete reshuffle of all the divisions is a bit heavy handed, and just binning gutted teams to the bottom would be a bloody good start.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.