User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Forget this restructuring junk. Change ownership lengths and give people a tick box.
Page:
 
Vilita
offline
Link
 
The beauty of promotion/relegation is that bad teams get relegated and good teams get promoted. The only problem that GLB has is that teams are sold back and gutted... or, excuse me, all players released without offering new contracts so not gutted, just left with little money and no players.

This makes bad teams in good leagues.

Instead of making everyone change leagues just because of the results of a poll where the majority of the responses will come from those in the lowest leagues of each region, just give owners the following tick boxes during the offseason.

Relegation:
[ ] Relegate my team, even if it finishes outside the relegation zone

Promotion:
[ ] Promote my team if a place in a higher league becomes available, even if I do not finish in a Promotion place




Thats it. So, if a team in the USA Pro has been completed crapped on, and the new owner shows up and wants nothing to do with that, instead of selling the team back over and over, they can just tick the "Relegate" box. Then they can be found a more level appropriate league automatically during the offseason. Lets say they are relegated from PRO to AAA for sake of argument. Then, the team with the best record of the teams in AAA who has "Promote my team even if we do not finish in the promotion places" selected will be promoted to PRO as well.

Its a rather simple solution that doesn't have to create a complete knee-jerk uphevel of the entire league system.

By keeping ownership restricted to entire seasons in length instead of ending every day during the season, the situation is also reduced. You can still have the option of selling back at any point, with the difference being, If you want to sell back during the season, you must pass the team off to a current GM and the team must still be in good operating condition. If you want to sell the team off otherwise, you can finish out the season and sell it back to CPU, maintaining the competition level of the team for the season then allowing it to get relegated per the above at the end of season if necessary
 
Knick
Sknickers
offline
Link
 
This might work well with the stickied thread "Move Sold Teams To Bottom of League"

I don't think this should be up to the new owner. If they can't compete, they go straight down pronto.

Another thing Bort posted is he doesn't like the idea of team ownerships ending mid-season, but he would rather avoid the whole 'inactive owner' situation.

BTW I've always said Regulation/Promotion worked, but since there are so many gutted teams right now its just not fast enough.

And when i say gutted I mean a team with no players and a shitty stadium/financial situation.
Last edited Sep 24, 2008 04:14:40
 
tycoon34
offline
Link
 
it would probably work at times, but it won't solve the gutting problem completely. People want gutted teams out of the proleauge completely, and some owners won't click that box because they want to "have a shot in the pro league."
 
Vilita
offline
Link
 
Nothing will solve gutting completely. But a one-time league restructuring doesn't solve gutting at all. At least this solution attempts to address the problem itself, not just acting as a cleanup of the aftermath.
 
Amyrlin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vilita
Nothing will solve gutting completely.


Banning gutting will solve gutting completely.

On the original idea, what happens when the team that is being shit on in USA Pro doesn't have anywhere to go because nobody in USA AAA has the promotion box checked?
 
Knick
Sknickers
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vilita
Nothing will solve gutting completely. But a one-time league restructuring doesn't solve gutting at all.


I agree.

However the owner shouldn't have the option to go up, stay, or go down.

Reshuffle, then enforce the Sold Teams to Bottom rigidly, and I don't see how the effects of gutting couldn't be minimized.
 
Vilita
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Amyrlin
Originally posted by Vilita

Nothing will solve gutting completely.


Banning gutting will solve gutting completely.

On the original idea, what happens when the team that is being shit on in USA Pro doesn't have anywhere to go because nobody in USA AAA has the promotion box checked?


They go to AA then. The team with the highest record that has the box checked will be promoted in their place, if no one in AAA (This is highly unlikely, as its more likely that teams will check it then not check it) has it checked then the team highest in AA will be selected and so on.
 
Knick
Sknickers
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vilita
Originally posted by Knick

OPL is just filled with dissatisfied owners... I know of 3 myself.

Ideally your system would work, but there are WAAAY too many jackass' who would rather play in a capped league and talk about how great they are than actually try.


It works fine in other games. At the end of each season they just drop sold teams down the league system, and promote (in order) the highest teams in their place that have the tick box selected. Bare bones, simple solution that does essentially everything the restructuring does, but is a continuous, not one time only solution. And it has the added benefit of preserving the league structures and rivalries we already have.


See I've been in a BBB league for a while and while everyone wants to keep the rivalries we all want to move up. Just different sides of the same street.
 
Vilita
offline
Link
 
Want to move up? Gosh, guess that proves my point, why do they all want to move up? I thought people just wanted competition. gee.

 
nottom
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Amyrlin
Originally posted by Vilita

Nothing will solve gutting completely.


Banning gutting will solve gutting completely.

On the original idea, what happens when the team that is being shit on in USA Pro doesn't have anywhere to go because nobody in USA AAA has the promotion box checked?



How do you "ban gutting"?
 
Saerin
offline
Link
 
You could ban gutting That isn't going to fix anything. Most players are loyal to the owner and not the team.

The mass restructuring will be a short term band aid if a plan to deal with gutted/sold teams is not implemented. this idea may have some merit but it still need more substance to it.

For instance 1 extra team from the league above is being relegated. the only two teams that have selected to be promoted are in different conferences and had identicle 11-5 records which one gets promoted?

 
Vilita
offline
Link
 
Which ever one has higher points differential. If the 1,000,000,000,000 to one chance that is the same, then either the one with the higher average rating or the one that wins a rand() battle gets promoted, not too difficult.

And again, I don't forsee that as an issue (just 2 teams). In other games that implement a similar system, it is typically more like 30 of 32 teams in a league have it selected, as opposed to 2 of 32.
 
Amyrlin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by nottom
Originally posted by Amyrlin

Originally posted by Vilita


Nothing will solve gutting completely.


Banning gutting will solve gutting completely.

On the original idea, what happens when the team that is being shit on in USA Pro doesn't have anywhere to go because nobody in USA AAA has the promotion box checked?



How do you "ban gutting"?


By... uh... banning it. Sorta like you ban collusion.

If someone guts, send them a message saying that it's not allowed and restore all player contracts to their pre-gut status.

It's not a solution I advocate. But it is possible.
 
Kirghiz
offline
Link
 
I just took over a gutted team, today in fact, in South America AAA#1. I didn't mean to end up with a team like this, but it is what it is. That league's average player levels are 24-34. The team has a total of 3 human owned players and they are inactive. The CPU players on the roster are level 18-23 mostly. In the first two games of the season before I took over, the average scores were 175-3. It has a little over 2 million in cash and only the inner ring of seats in the stadium. This team will be impossible to compete with this season, next season, and probably the season after that. Keep in mind that I don't have a problem with taking a gutted team necessarily, I like a challenge, but even if this team gets demoted in the offseason it still won't be able to compete in the next league down either.

I see myself as having two options here. The first, sell the team back and piss away 500 flex points doesn't much appeal to me. The other is sign a bunch of scrubs out of the D-League for peanuts and aggressively build the stadium with whatever money I can make while losing games 1,000-0 and hope to get dropped down one level per season. Either way there is nothing fun about this team. The more I think about it the more I think I will just sell this piece of crap back, lose five bucks, and not sign up for another team until there is an "expansion team only" checkbox.

The thing that needs to happen is the gutted teams need to just be deleted altogether and promote teams and expand teams accordingly to fill in the holes. Any players on the teams get released to free agency. It is the best thing for the competitive balance and it is the most fair thing for new owners coming in. There is no reason for the powers that be to alienate the people that pay money to play this game. It is just bad customer service to expect people to have to take over these teams. Hell, it isn't even fun playing against one of these teams if you are on a respectable team.
 
Vilita
offline
Link
 
Yea, its true.

Honestly, everyone is on the wrong track here. Okay, not everyone. But seriously.

A) Reshuffling the leagues solves nothing. 15 seconds after the leagues are reshuffled, teams will be gutted and sold back, and the effect of the reshuffling will already be lost.

B) Increasing the Promotion/Relegation places is only *slightly* more effective. Yes, after 2-3 seasons all the gutted teams should be weeded out... but there will be more to go ontop of that, they won't fall far and it will take many seasons for a gutted team from the top league to rebuild at the bototm. There are just as many teams who finish in the top 12 in the league that are sold back at/near the end of a season (and all players end on day 40) as those that finish bottom 4. Such a solution does nothing to address this at all


So again, there is no ONE solution. But I think it would be far more productive to do a series of simple things...

IE:

1) Enforce the freaking rule about having 40 players on the team. If a team is not allowed to cut a player to go below 40, they shouldn't be able to TRADE a player to go below 40 either. A team should be required to have 40 players, no loopholes.

2) Follow suggestion above, allow teams to be voluntarily relegated at any point during the offseason and teams promoted accordingly from the league(s) below

3) If for some reason it is too difficult to require a team to actually maintain enough players to field a team, then enforce some sort of penalty on an owner who sells back a team without enough players to field a team with.

And the simplest, and most important small feature IMO...

4) Use the "Chemistry Grace Period" as a co-ownership period where both the previous and new owners can offer contract negotiations to the players. This way, owners don't have to send emergency end on day 40 contracts, fire sale trades or cuts for fear of the team being taken over by a deadbeat owner. If the new owner of the team doesn't log in for the first 2 days of the chem grace period, then the old owner can do a fire sale on the third day. If the new owner logs in and is cool and has direction, most of the players might want to stay.

Just give them the chance. Because right now, everyone is so worried about being gutted or benched, that they gut to prevent being gutted or benched. Kind of like when they burn fires in anticipation of a spreading fire...
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.