User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
Vilita
offline
Link
 
This poll is extremely unfair, because fundamentally, there are more teams in the bottom league of each region then in the rest of each region. Obviously these teams are going to have no concern over there position in the league structure if they have no where to go but up if they happen to have a good team.
 
Welsh76
offline
Link
 
Does is really matter what league you're in if every game will be competitive?

It's got to be better than the current system full of gutted teams.
 
Vilita
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Welsh76
Does is really matter what league you're in if every game will be competitive?

It's got to be better than the current system full of gutted teams.


Full? Its not an epidemic. Its a problem yes, but do we really have to move around 29 teams in a league because 3 have been gutted?

So we have one or two games per season that don't have to be game planned for, so does the rest of the league so its not as big of a deal.

And anyway the whole restructuring thing won't matter, because there will be just as many gutted teams in good leagues immediately following the restructuring when people sell back teams because they don't like the league they ended up in, the fact that they are in a league with none of the rival teams they are used to playing or in a region they do not associate with and they'd rather just sell back and start over.

Restructuring is not a solution, its a band aid that will negate all the work teams have put into the game the first 3 seasons, and essentially do nothing to actually fix the problem its designed to address
 
Knick
Sknickers
offline
Link
 
in one of my teams BBB league we have 6 gutted teams in the CONFERENCE. 6/16 /= 3/32
 
Vilita
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Knick
in one of my teams BBB league we have 6 gutted teams in the CONFERENCE. 6/16 /= 3/32


BBB Is the bottom league in the pyramid - All that proves is the system is working itself out nicely...
 
Knick
Sknickers
offline
Link
 
I've heard of an A league with 5 gutted teams in a conference.

This IS an epidemic, and I don't see your rationale against that.
 
Knick
Sknickers
offline
Link
 
another note

Why is this in 'Bugs'

Be constructive, have a plan, and post in 'Suggestions'
 
Vilita
offline
Link
 
So because, potentially, two leagues at the bottom level of their respective pyramid shockingly have 5 or 6 low skilled teams (Surprise, thats what "Relegation" Does) - there is a gutting epidemic?

I think you need to brush up on your language, a team is not gutted simply because it has a poor lineup. It also has to have been financially misguided with intent.

People selling back teams and leaving them with little to no players = epidemic
"gutting" = not epidemic

 
Vilita
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Knick
another note

Why is this in 'Bugs'

Be constructive, have a plan, and post in 'Suggestions'


Or, you can be constructive yourself, and actually look in suggestions before you tell me to, and see that I already posted the plan, so you don't have to suggest I do something I already have!
Last edited Sep 24, 2008 04:12:58
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vilita
This poll is extremely unfair, because fundamentally, there are more teams in the bottom league of each region then in the rest of each region. Obviously these teams are going to have no concern over there position in the league structure if they have no where to go but up if they happen to have a good team.


Wait, you mean like it's fundamentally unfair that Pro teams starting out in Pro for no good reason have less say in the matter?

LMFAO. Sorry, but you're looking out for yourself when your own franchise never had to promote once.

 
islander1
offline
Link
 
on a side note, I wasn't completely happy with the poll options either.

I don't want to end up in like Eastern Europe AAA just because a sorting mechanism determines that's where my team may belong. I do agree with the reshuffle but I want it to stay within each independent region.

I mean seriously, if your team is pro caliber in personnel, guess what? You'll stay there.
 
1VBChaos
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Knick
I've heard of an A league with 5 gutted teams in a conference.

This IS an epidemic, and I don't see your rationale against that.


Rationale is simple - he has winning team(s) and doesn't like the idea of actually having to compete with too many other winning teams.

GLB is a minority-centric game. If you got here early enough and/or got in with the right people you win things. The rest of us just make up the numbers, which is why so many people come in, take a team, realise they have no chance of competing, so leave.

 
islander1
offline
Link
 
Oh and just saw Knick's quote.

USA AA3 East has like 6 or 7 gutted teams now. I lose count
 
Vilita
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by islander1

Wait, you mean like it's fundamentally unfair that Pro teams starting out in Pro for no good reason have less say in the matter?


No good reason? What did you expect us to do? Start out in AAA when it didn't exist? Was no one supposed to buy a team in season 1? Your response is just as misguided as the poll

I don't care what the reason is that my team is where it is. The only reason I bought my team was because I liked the region it was in, and I was familiar with the league it was in. If I ended up in another region, or another league, with absolutely no choice in the matter because of a poll voted on 95% of users in other leagues, then I would sell back my team, and voila, the epidemic has started once again, and the restructuring will already have begun to fail.

Its just using my own self as an example as to why a one time restructuring of teams does absolutely nothing to solve/prevent/fix the problem. It will make for one competitive season at most, and after that one season, there will just be more gutted teams showing up, more bitching about them, and finally people will start to develop more ideas that fix it. I don't see why we have to restructure the leagues to begin with, when its not going to do anything at all to address the actual problem, which is the continuous selling back of teams and leaving them with little to no assets where by a player IS an asset and surprisingly, unlike what the admin team seems to think, you can NOT build a team capable of competing in AAA on the reset cash amount of $500,000. Or even the new default amount of $1,500,000. Its fundamental maths. When the average level of a league is 25, and the minimum signing bonus on a level 25 player is $100,000... holy crap, so giving a team with no players $500,000 to start with means they can only sign 5 players good enough to play in their league. Yea, thats a big help.

I wonder why teams don't re-develop themselves quicker in higher leagues
 
Vilita
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by 1VBChaos
Originally posted by Knick

I've heard of an A league with 5 gutted teams in a conference.

This IS an epidemic, and I don't see your rationale against that.


Rationale is simple - he has winning team(s) and doesn't like the idea of actually having to compete with too many other winning teams.



No, the rationale is simple. I don't want 4 seasons of rivalries potentially broken up to do a one-time reshuffling which does absolutely zero to address the problem its trying to counter act. Come up with a solution that addresses the problem itself.

Reshuffling is like sending a janitor in to a long hall way to clean up the trash left behind by people passing between two office buildings. Guess what, people leave trash behind every day and the janitor has to come clean it up every day.

Or... they can just add a trash bin in the middle of the hall way and let people throw their own trash into it, janitor not needed.


Thats reshuffling. The only way it solves anything is if it takes place at the end of every season, other wise, the trash will just continue to pile up no matter what.

And if the leagues were reshuffled at the end of the season, promotion/relegation would be meaningless, trophies would be meaningless and the game would lose some of its luster, so reshuffling is unfortunately not the solution, regardless of what league the team I inherited happened to be in when I got it.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.