User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > I'm throwing my red flag on this one, I need a review ref!!
USCGuardsman
offline
Link
 
Can someone please let me know why this was not a TD??http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=172402&pbp_id=1275109 The TE clearly breaks the plain and this was 3rd and 10. It resulted in a 10 yard play. Next play was a 4th and ZERO on the ZERO and my SIMM went for a pass?!?!?! Did the SIMM think this was a first and 10? Because it surely was dumb to throw here!

 
Robbnva
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by USCGuardsman
Can someone please let me know why this was not a TD??http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=172402&pbp_id=1275109 The TE clearly breaks the plain and this was 3rd and 10. It resulted in a 10 yard play. Next play was a 4th and ZERO on the ZERO and my SIMM went for a pass?!?!?! Did the SIMM think this was a first and 10? Because it surely was dumb to throw here!



graphics are not accurate. text is accurate. NOT A BUG.
 
Weather
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by USCGuardsman
Can someone please let me know why this was not a TD??http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=172402&pbp_id=1275109 The TE clearly breaks the plain and this was 3rd and 10. It resulted in a 10 yard play. Next play was a 4th and ZERO on the ZERO and my SIMM went for a pass?!?!?! Did the SIMM think this was a first and 10? Because it surely was dumb to throw here!



Lots of NFL teams throw on the 1 yd line.
 
USCGuardsman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Robbnva
Originally posted by USCGuardsman

Can someone please let me know why this was not a TD??http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=172402&pbp_id=1275109 The TE clearly breaks the plain and this was 3rd and 10. It resulted in a 10 yard play. Next play was a 4th and ZERO on the ZERO and my SIMM went for a pass?!?!?! Did the SIMM think this was a first and 10? Because it surely was dumb to throw here!



graphics are not accurate. text is accurate. NOT A BUG.


well if Text was accurate, than this should have been a 9 yard gain, followed by a 4th and 1. If it was more than 10 yards needed for the TD, i should have been able to have a first down. So, no it's not accurate.
 
Mightyhalo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by USCGuardsman
Originally posted by Robbnva

Originally posted by USCGuardsman


Can someone please let me know why this was not a TD??http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=172402&pbp_id=1275109 The TE clearly breaks the plain and this was 3rd and 10. It resulted in a 10 yard play. Next play was a 4th and ZERO on the ZERO and my SIMM went for a pass?!?!?! Did the SIMM think this was a first and 10? Because it surely was dumb to throw here!



graphics are not accurate. text is accurate. NOT A BUG.


well if Text was accurate, than this should have been a 9 yard gain, followed by a 4th and 1. If it was more than 10 yards needed for the TD, i should have been able to have a first down. So, no it's not accurate.


You do know that even in the big ol NFL, it might read 3rd and 10, but its actually 3rd and 10 1/2. But it still reads as 3rd and 10, not 3rd and 11. So even though your guy might have made 10 yards, he was still short, since you truly weren't only 10 yards exactly away. Critical thinking exercises might be a good thing to look into.
Last edited Sep 22, 2008 17:16:16
 
USCGuardsman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mightyhalo
Originally posted by USCGuardsman

Originally posted by Robbnva


Originally posted by USCGuardsman



Can someone please let me know why this was not a TD??http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=172402&pbp_id=1275109 The TE clearly breaks the plain and this was 3rd and 10. It resulted in a 10 yard play. Next play was a 4th and ZERO on the ZERO and my SIMM went for a pass?!?!?! Did the SIMM think this was a first and 10? Because it surely was dumb to throw here!



graphics are not accurate. text is accurate. NOT A BUG.


well if Text was accurate, than this should have been a 9 yard gain, followed by a 4th and 1. If it was more than 10 yards needed for the TD, i should have been able to have a first down. So, no it's not accurate.


You do know that even in the big ol NFL, it might read 3rd and 10, but its actually 3rd and 10 1/2. But it still reads as 3rd and 10, not 3rd and 11. So even though your guy might have made 10 yards, he was still short, since you truly weren't only 10 yards exactly away. Critical thinking exercises might be a good thing to look into.


Well yea that's what i was saying, if it was 10 yards and an inch, that should mean there is a first down mark available, would'nt you think? That's my whole arguement, it shouldnt have been 3rd and goal, but 3rd and 10.


I know some of you may think that this is a miniscule complaint, but to me it cost my team a game. If it was anything more than 10 yards to the goal, then I should have been able to get a first down. This is based on American football right?
Last edited Sep 22, 2008 17:39:11
 
Welsh76
offline
Link
 
There's nothing wrong with a short pass that close to the goalline, a lot of teams are still using the basic AI which uses cover 2 and puts the safeties at the back of the endzone.

I've scored a lot of points by throwing against a cover 2 defense this way, you should always play cover 0 when defending this close to the goalline
 
GeniusAskew
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by USCGuardsman
Lots of NFL teams throw on the 1 yd line.


Tonight, Favre threw for a 2-pt conversion on the FREAKING NINE INCH LINE, and missed.
 
LSUTigerJosh
offline
Link
 
Saints can't run on a third and 1 at all.
 
Phantom_Opera
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Robbnva
Originally posted by USCGuardsman

Can someone please let me know why this was not a TD??http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=172402&pbp_id=1275109 The TE clearly breaks the plain and this was 3rd and 10. It resulted in a 10 yard play. Next play was a 4th and ZERO on the ZERO and my SIMM went for a pass?!?!?! Did the SIMM think this was a first and 10? Because it surely was dumb to throw here!



graphics are not accurate. text is accurate. NOT A BUG.


Not Accurate should = bug!

Make the damn sim accurate. After further review... TD!!! imo. There is no 0 yard line, it is the goal line and needs to be debugged. Has happened to me before, but I got over.
 
Mike Rogers
Lead Tester
offline
Link
 
Its pretty much a bug, but only in the reporting not in the actual play mechanics/decision making etc.

The play was 3rd and 10, you gained 9.9 yards, the reporting rounded it up to 10 yards, but you failed to gain the full ten yards so the Goal Line was not reached.

See various TDs or first downs that are reported as 'No Gain'.

Even seen safeties awarded for 'No Gain' plays where no Tfl is awarded.

And anyone talking about the replays looking accurate, have you seen the size of your players?

Either way, it has no effect on the result of the play, or even the game, merely on how its reported to you.
Last edited Sep 23, 2008 04:48:27
 
superpunk
offline
Link
 
Yeah.

The ball is not nearly six feet long, as it would appear in the graphical representation.
 
RMiller517
offline
Link
 
Thread locked by moderator.
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.