User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
CoolChuck
offline
Link
 
I've noticed in games, for a couple of teams, that the LBs seem to behave strangely when the opponents runs the ball from the I formation. As soon as the ball is snapped, all 3 seem to retreat into zone coverage, even though they aren't set that way. I have the AI set, in the defensive AI, for the underneath coverage to be man to man. I have asked that the personal tactics be set differently for all 3 LBs, yet they all act the same. Here are some examples:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=189907&pbp_id=800947
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=189907&pbp_id=801319
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=189907&pbp_id=801369
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=189907&pbp_id=801636

This happens very often, and I probably have even better examples, but those are just the first several that I ran across.
 
bignastee
offline
Link
 
What is your coverage set at in the D AI for I formation?

It looks like they're dropping back to cover receivers, since it's set to man underneath, but need to know what output your D goes to with this formation and down & distance.
 
CoolChuck
offline
Link
 
Formation - 4-3
Defense Shell - Cover1
Underneath Coverage - Man Underneath
Coverage Distance - Medium
Play Focus - Balanced

But, I don't believe they are dropping back into coverage. This behavior only happens on running plays from the I formation. When there is actually a pass, they don't move backwards into an apparent Zone, they actually go toward the receivers they are supposed to be covering, like in this example:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=189907&pbp_id=801395
 
CoolChuck
offline
Link
 
any ideas?
 
PinTBC
offline
Link
 
I'm seeing the same problem in the 3-4 defense with the outside linebackers specifically. I posted a thread about it before I saw yours.

There seems to be a rather bad pathing issue somewhere.

My thread

http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=1092868

PinTBC
 
turnit643
offline
Link
 
GLB LB's don't play with any sort of reading hop-step to begin each play. They all begin to get into drops _before_ making their run reads. When they do read run (how quickly they realize it's a run is largely vision-dependent ... though you'd think the "read run" bonus in the player tactics would also have some effect), their ability to stop their drop, change direction, and accelerate toward the play is where their agility comes in. You'll see high-Vision + high-Agility LB's still take those drops, but cut them off and come up much quicker. (I'd guess that many of the LB's that are really flying out are high speed guys.)

However, when faced with a pass play, they will read it immediately and track their man-under assignment or head for their designated piece of grass in a zone-under.

Also, on a related note, the first step for blitzing LB's is toward the LOS and they will come without hesitation on pass plays but will pause momentarily where they are at when they recognize a run (to locate the runner's path??) before continuing.

Stacking the LB's gives them a starting point closer to the LOS, so when they get into their drops, they don't fall off quite as far before their read&react moment happens ... but getting up to the point-of-attack area quicker also seems to make them more *visible* to lead blockers who might otherwise elect to take on another defender, so there is some give-and-take.
 
PinTBC
offline
Link
 
Except that this movement is not part of a pass play. On a pass play, they stay put and pick up the guy they are supposed to cover and the play works well. For some reason (and this was happening a lot last season), on a run, they bail and vector off at about 45 degrees away from the line of scrimmage.

This leaves a gaping hole in the defensive line, and really needs someone to look at it.

Again, it resembles the exact same pathing issues Bort fixed last season, and seems to be prevalent in cover 1 schemes with man underneath. I did NOT see it happening on the other team I have access to that went straight man to man.

PinTBC
 
turnit643
offline
Link
 
I may not have been clear. I realize that this is not part of a pass play and I agree that it would be nice to have it at least toned down if the LB's are not going to pause before making their read.

What I'm seeing is this ...

Underneath coverage set to either "man" or "zone" and the LB's in question not set to blitz.

A. Pass play = LB's read "pass" immediately.
They hurry to chase down their man assignment or drop to their zone.

B. Run play = LB's DO NOT read "run" immediately.
They still react as if it's a pass play and - without a man coverage assignment defined since it's a run play - they default to a zone coverage drop. By the time they figure out that it is in fact a run play, they then have to gather themselves, stop, change direction, and charge up toward the runner. The ground they cover while doing it (and the time it takes to do it) opens the "gaping hole".

--

Perhaps LB individual tactics for "play type focus" should have a stronger, more defined effect on their initial reaction to each play ...

Run Focus - first step or two toward LOS, then react and recover (hustle to their zone or to their man assignment) if they read pass.

Balanced focus - pause in place momentarily and read pass/run.

Pass focus - first step or two away from LOS, then react and recover if they read run.

I don't know how much the individual LB tactics for "play type focus" currently play into all of this.
 
PinTBC
offline
Link
 
Well,we haven't seemed to be able to catch a Mod or admin's attention, so who knows what's up with this. I'd seriously advise to stay out of cover 1 settings, they are screwing up the linebackers. Go to straight man, it seems to be working much closer to as desired.

Turnit,

I don't disagree with your description of what is happening, I disagree that it should happen. It doesn't seem to happen on straight man coverage, or on pass coverage. I can guarentee you that I have no zone settings on my defense, so the linebackers should NOT be falling into anything that resembles a deep zone.

Even though I agree that I'd like to see the individual player settings do something like what you described, it still strikes me as VERY odd that I'm only seeing this as a result of cover 1 in my secondary.

PinTBC
 
RMiller517
offline
Link
 
Thread locked by moderator.
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.