User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > USA AAA Leagues > USA AAA #2 > Bort comments on the gutting epidemic
Page:
 
Yellow
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by
Anyway, in regards to this topic, I agree that it's a problem, which is why I mentioned it in my start of the season announcement as a priority to address this season.

A one time increased relegation/promotion will not fix the problem. All it will do is band-aid it for a season or two until enough teams gut or give up again. It also doesn't address what to do with teams that give up midseason and lose a bunch of players, or teams who never bother to try very hard, etc.

Moving teams to the bottom tier when sold seems like a good start to me, but it still doesn't address the problem with mid-season team sales. Sure, you can say "don't allow mid-season sales" like I have seen many times, but then you just get a team who quits and is full of inactives, with no tactics being set, not getting any better, and you end up with the same problem. So, I think that's only part of a possible solution.

What about teams who just aren't any good because their builds suck or they don't try or they set stupid tactics? We can't force them to be good. People aren't being paid to run the teams, so they have no reason to try and be competitive if they don't want to bother. If we could add more incentives to try, and incentives to not gut your team, it might help, but I don't know what those might be other than not giving a refund when you sell a gutted team or something.

If this was a super easy fix, we would have fixed it by now, trust me.



He kinda has a point. Though i think a temporary fix to buy some time would be a good idea.
Last edited Sep 21, 2008 22:47:04
 
Link
 
You've got to move the gutted teams. That simple for that part of the problem. You develop the system and move gutted teams at the end of every season.

Want people to stick around? How about we stop with the pink thong with +10 vision crap and try fixing the problems with the sim and stop tweaking things without announcing them? That will help.

If teams build sucks, then they should be relegated because that means they should be the worst team in the league. All these gutted teams allow the teams with sucky builds to hang around.

That's half the problem if not more all addressed. I don't see most of this being as tricky to fix as Bort says.
 
BloodRunsCold
offline
Link
 
I have a question for team owners/GMs.

I obviously hate the gutted teams too and they ruin the stats which would be my favorite part of this game if they meant anything at all. But there is always one thing that bothers me when I hear "just send the gutted teams to the bottom".

And that is the obvious who moves up. Now from my POV, I dont care who moves up to AAA as better competition would be cool/fun. BUT my question comes from what if you guys are asked to move up.

For example, palmer_garnett. The Who Dey are one of the better teams in the East. I would say they have a chance to advance to Pro but are not the favorites. Say that you are the 3rd best team (random number) and 3 USA Pro East teams are gutted. You would then, in theory, get pushed up to Pro. Even though you didnt even make it to the conference championship.

I guess my point, is that it kind of make trophies and things worthless. I mean I have worked really hard for my team to advance twice and I think we have as good of a chance as anyone in the West to win that trophy. But are we going to be forced to advance to Pro without the trophy? Do we just want to advance to Pro and it is not about winning AAA?

I have been having a hard time answering this myself. If Bort came to me and said, you finished 2nd or 3rd but because of gutted teams you "win" advancement. Shrug, that would be tough. And then what about those teams that like their league and finish 4th-5th but have gutted teams above them, do they advance? Would you guys advance to Pro without winning AAA?

I know in some leagues there are 8 gutted teams. Is the 8th best team going to advance a league?? They get a reward yet are not even a top team in their league?

I am not so sure it is super easy problem to fix. In theory too, if there were more than 16 gutted teams (if lol) then the entire bottom rung will get brought up. Because you have to then replace the gutted teams AND the teams that left to replace gutted teams.
 
Link
 
I understand your concern.

I'm not that worried about the trophies. I mean I want one, but at the same time, I think the best teams need to be moved up to fill in for gutted teams. If an 8th best team in one league moves up, that's fine. If they were good enough to stay, they'll stay once the move up. If they weren't, then they'll likely end up being relegated.

I guess bort could ask teams if they want to be moved up before moving them. I don't think many would say no, but there are those that will because they want to move up by winning a trophy. To me, trophies are just for bragging rights. Besides, as I told OFG and RRY when they first arrived, getting a trophy in a lower league doesn't mean anything until you prove your worth in your new league.

Again, I think the main thing is getting the best teams moved to the upper leagues to make things competitive. I would rather have 32 solid teams in USA Pro, AAA #1, and AAA #2 rather than only move 2 teams up a year and leave several gutted teams in each league. That would also allow the gutted teams a chance to compete against each other in the low leagues, thus causing less turnover with owners with gutted teams. Owners simply don't want a gutted team in a league like Pro or either AAA league.
Last edited Sep 22, 2008 08:57:38
 
Adderfist
offline
Link
 
I would love to see 8 or 4 up/down at least then you start moving bad teams and not just gutted ones. Fuck you could scale the up/down movement.

Pro -4
AAA +/- 4
AA +/- 4
A +/- 8
BBB + 8
 
Link
 
Here's the fucking deal:

A solution to the problem is necessary, but you must fix the symptoms as well - especially when the symptoms are creating additional problems. You think people sailing across the ocean when their ship springs a leak sit down and pontificate on how to build a better boat? THAT'S NOT HELPING THEIR IMMEDIATE SITUATION.


I don't know why people (as in Bort and his fanbois) want to fuse the symptoms of gutting and the systemic cause of gutting. They are related, but the two issues have different solutions. If Bort fixed the case of gutting, we'd still have Pac 10 Blitz for at least 5 more seasons.


*only posting this here becuase if I find the thread where people are actually talking about it, the fanbois will go bonkers.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by BloodRunsCold

For example, palmer_garnett. The Who Dey are one of the better teams in the East. I would say they have a chance to advance to Pro but are not the favorites. Say that you are the 3rd best team (random number) and 3 USA Pro East teams are gutted. You would then, in theory, get pushed up to Pro. Even though you didnt even make it to the conference championship.

I guess my point, is that it kind of make trophies and things worthless. I mean I have worked really hard for my team to advance twice and I think we have as good of a chance as anyone in the West to win that trophy. But are we going to be forced to advance to Pro without the trophy? Do we just want to advance to Pro and it is not about winning AAA?

I have been having a hard time answering this myself. If Bort came to me and said, you finished 2nd or 3rd but because of gutted teams you "win" advancement. Shrug, that would be tough. And then what about those teams that like their league and finish 4th-5th but have gutted teams above them, do they advance? Would you guys advance to Pro without winning AAA?


There are teams in the Pros that haven't won shit. Do they deserve to stick around by merit of being created before yours? Yes, more respect goes to a team that has won their way there, but if a team gets promoted without winning and shows they don't belong, there are mechanisms to make sure they won't stay.
 
Mofo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by phthalatemagic
Here's the fucking deal:

A solution to the problem is necessary, but you must fix the symptoms as well - especially when the symptoms are creating additional problems. You think people sailing across the ocean when their ship springs a leak sit down and pontificate on how to build a better boat? THAT'S NOT HELPING THEIR IMMEDIATE SITUATION.


I don't know why people (as in Bort and his fanbois) want to fuse the symptoms of gutting and the systemic cause of gutting. They are related, but the two issues have different solutions. If Bort fixed the case of gutting, we'd still have Pac 10 Blitz for at least 5 more seasons.


*only posting this here becuase if I find the thread where people are actually talking about it, the fanbois will go bonkers.


Exactly. who gives a shit if it's just a band-aid something needs done. Fix the leagues now and give us a few competitive seasons while you come up with some all-encompassing solution or whatever the fuck your trying to come up with.
 
Yellow
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by phthalatemagic
Here's the fucking deal:

You think people sailing across the ocean when their ship springs a leak sit down and pontificate on how to build a better boat?


Winner.

 
libb23
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Yellow
Originally posted by phthalatemagic

Here's the fucking deal:

You think people sailing across the ocean when their ship springs a leak sit down and pontificate on how to build a better boat?


Winner.



+1 here

 
Adderfist
offline
Link
 
Buy the man a beer. Said it so eloquently, I stole it
 
Link
 
Haha really? Most of the stuff I type here, I'm pretty distracted by actual work, and I figure it doesn't make any sense. (doesn't stop me from typing it though)
 
coyote4848
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Yellow
Originally posted by phthalatemagic

Here's the fucking deal:

You think people sailing across the ocean when their ship springs a leak sit down and pontificate on how to build a better boat?


Winner.




That's a great line....lol. Very true.
 
Faux Bear
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Yellow
Originally posted by phthalatemagic

Here's the fucking deal:

You think people sailing across the ocean when their ship springs a leak sit down and pontificate on how to build a better boat?


Winner.



and the Gold Medal for Truthiness goes to...
 
Dyslexia
offline
Link
 
I think the poll for relegation is shit.

If everyone is relegated by level the Beardogs are gonna be back in A, and I worry that Bort is too lazy to notice or care.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.