User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
Pburg
offline
Link
 
Wow....looks like it is another season of bullcrap teams...how in the hell are there teams in this league with no starters over level 9...it is complete rubbish.
 
wrongway
offline
Link
 
It can't be good for the game...

 
islander1
offline
Link
 
it's not. but it's a long established and until very recently ignored complaint.

maybe next season they will tweak promotions to get all the horrible teams out of upper divisions.
 
Chavez255
offline
Link
 
we all might as well get used to it, because no matter how they tweak it, it will always going to be a problem.
 
Lost Time
offline
Link
 
Not if they just throw in a dump league. all rebuilds will go there and they have to work their way back in. It's harsh, but so is a gutted team being killed 200-0 and screwing up all stats in the conferences. There should be an average minimum level to remain in a league, if they don't make that level they are booted out and the next closet leveled team comes in to represent
 
Chavez255
offline
Link
 
but these guts happen midseason sometimes, then what? a conference with 4 gutted teams will only have 12 games? that will be worse for stats.
 
Omle
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Lost Time
Not if they just throw in a dump league. all rebuilds will go there and they have to work their way back in. It's harsh, but so is a gutted team being killed 200-0 and screwing up all stats in the conferences. There should be an average minimum level to remain in a league, if they don't make that level they are booted out and the next closet leveled team comes in to represent


That is a good but how do they fill the spots they remove them from.
Promote? How do they choose to promote?
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Janine
Originally posted by Lost Time

Not if they just throw in a dump league. all rebuilds will go there and they have to work their way back in. It's harsh, but so is a gutted team being killed 200-0 and screwing up all stats in the conferences. There should be an average minimum level to remain in a league, if they don't make that level they are booted out and the next closet leveled team comes in to represent


That is a good but how do they fill the spots they remove them from.
Promote? How do they choose to promote?


This decision is easy. I posted it over on GLB forum. Here you go:

Increase promotions this way:

- Right now the playoff winner goes up. one team per conference.

- When picking a second team have the conference finalist promote.

- If it comes down to third and fourth teams, I would go by regular season records. This will ensure that the most competitive teams will go up.

I don't believe under any circumstances should more then 4 teams in a conference promote.
 
Bountytaker
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by islander1
Originally posted by Janine

Originally posted by Lost Time


Not if they just throw in a dump league. all rebuilds will go there and they have to work their way back in. It's harsh, but so is a gutted team being killed 200-0 and screwing up all stats in the conferences. There should be an average minimum level to remain in a league, if they don't make that level they are booted out and the next closet leveled team comes in to represent


That is a good but how do they fill the spots they remove them from.
Promote? How do they choose to promote?


This decision is easy. I posted it over on GLB forum. Here you go:

Increase promotions this way:

- Right now the playoff winner goes up. one team per conference.

- When picking a second team have the conference finalist promote.

- If it comes down to third and fourth teams, I would go by regular season records. This will ensure that the most competitive teams will go up.

I don't believe under any circumstances should more then 4 teams in a conference promote.


What if there's only one extra spot opening up. Which conference finalist do you take? The possible tie-breakers could cause more harm than good.
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bountytaker
Originally posted by islander1

Originally posted by Janine


Originally posted by Lost Time



Not if they just throw in a dump league. all rebuilds will go there and they have to work their way back in. It's harsh, but so is a gutted team being killed 200-0 and screwing up all stats in the conferences. There should be an average minimum level to remain in a league, if they don't make that level they are booted out and the next closet leveled team comes in to represent


That is a good but how do they fill the spots they remove them from.
Promote? How do they choose to promote?


This decision is easy. I posted it over on GLB forum. Here you go:

Increase promotions this way:

- Right now the playoff winner goes up. one team per conference.

- When picking a second team have the conference finalist promote.

- If it comes down to third and fourth teams, I would go by regular season records. This will ensure that the most competitive teams will go up.

I don't believe under any circumstances should more then 4 teams in a conference promote.


What if there's only one extra spot opening up. Which conference finalist do you take? The possible tie-breakers could cause more harm than good.


That's a good point. The tiebreakers would be a headache. Worst case scenario, make it random/luck. Best case scenario, have the game schedule a friendly or 'qualifier' to see who gets it.

In any case, I don't think there are any viable complaints. The objective is to have the most competitive upper divisions.


 
kenmoody
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by islander1
Originally posted by Bountytaker

Originally posted by islander1


Originally posted by Janine



Originally posted by Lost Time




Not if they just throw in a dump league. all rebuilds will go there and they have to work their way back in. It's harsh, but so is a gutted team being killed 200-0 and screwing up all stats in the conferences. There should be an average minimum level to remain in a league, if they don't make that level they are booted out and the next closet leveled team comes in to represent


That is a good but how do they fill the spots they remove them from.
Promote? How do they choose to promote?


This decision is easy. I posted it over on GLB forum. Here you go:

Increase promotions this way:

- Right now the playoff winner goes up. one team per conference.

- When picking a second team have the conference finalist promote.

- If it comes down to third and fourth teams, I would go by regular season records. This will ensure that the most competitive teams will go up.

I don't believe under any circumstances should more then 4 teams in a conference promote.


What if there's only one extra spot opening up. Which conference finalist do you take? The possible tie-breakers could cause more harm than good.


That's a good point. The tiebreakers would be a headache. Worst case scenario, make it random/luck. Best case scenario, have the game schedule a friendly or 'qualifier' to see who gets it.

In any case, I don't think there are any viable complaints. The objective is to have the most competitive upper divisions.




Personally, I think this is a great idea. Would ultimately reward the teams which continually strive to build and grow, would ensure that those teams move to and remain in divisions which are consistently competitive, and would make the game a better one for the most valuable customers, the ones who keep dumping money into it.

There are some challenges and concerns, no doubt, but the advantages outweigh the disadvantages for sure.

 
Omle
offline
Link
 
Posting this thread so admins can see it, Keep discussing
I like these ideas very much.
Last edited Sep 22, 2008 13:01:04
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
I figure in the end, there's one response to anyone complaining someone else got a free promotion slot -> win your conference next season.

Odds are good though that most seasons you'll see 2 teams per division promotable though. It's the nature of this game. It's only getting worse - not better.

I think the only team with a legitimate gripe would possible be a conference finalist who DIDN'T get to promote (but the other did). That would suck pretty hard. I'd really like to see a 'playoff' in that situation.

However, if it can't be facilitated at all - formally or informally - then ultimately, luck wins and the loser just has to take care of the first sentence.
Last edited Sep 22, 2008 13:05:01
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Janine
Posting this thread so admins can see it, Keep discussing
I like these ideas very much.


Good to hear!

Yeah, in the end, like you and others have said, the devil is in the details.

No two promotion situations are exactly the same, however it's possible to develop a 'fair enough' system that will ensure that the upper tiers are properly populated, and the gutted teams will be in the lower division(s) where the competition level will be reasonable for them, too. This isn't just about good teams going up - its also about new teams not getting destroyed 200-0 14 times a season. This has got to contribute to the repeat gutting of the same teams.

 
Bountytaker
offline
Link
 
Oh..don't forget. Technically, in many cases, there would be 4 conference runner-up's vying for the extra openings (two in each league that feed into the upper division).


Playoffs would be one option, for sure. And, I agree that, with the way things are going, there'd likely be not enough good teams to fill spots, as opposed to vice-versa.


I do wonder, though, if we're just moving closer and closer to that suggestion from a while back, where each year we just realign the leagues.

I don't like it, because I like having rivalries. But, if it gets to the point where I have two rivals and 9+ cupcakes, I just may have to change my mind.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.