User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > [BUG] - single back big formation doesn't call proper play
Page:
 
RAPB
offline
Link
 

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=187411&pbp_id=1002785

- looks like a single back big formation to me (2 TE)
- our AI calls 3 plays: 2x cover 2 plays and 1x a 3-4 cover 1 play vs. that single back big

Input is set at
time blank
any spot - any spot
Down 1 - 4
yards blank
score blank
formation: single back big
Number of WR's in Set: between 0 and 2

... so what does bring up a that defensive play?


the (closest looking) cover 1 play [output] we should be calling is:

3-4
cover 1
man-to-man Underneath Coverage
medium Coverage Distance
Balanced Play Focus
LB Shift: Center (no shift)
Max # Blitzers: 0


- the shown play isn't even in our playbook (looks like a 3-4, cover 0 or cover 1 with FS-blitz, LB shift weak side)

- the only 3-4 cover 0 plays (output) are called at these inputs:

Time Remaining in quarter: blank
Ball Spot (yard line): any - any
Down: between 3 and 4
Yards to first down: Between 0 and 3
Score Difference: blank
Opponent's Formation: Shotgun
Number of WR's in Set: Between 3 and 3

Time Remaining in quarter: blank
Ball Spot (yard line): any - any
Down: between 1 and 4
Yards to first down: blank
Score Difference: blank
Opponent's Formation: I (any variation)
Number of WR's in Set: Between 2 and 2


Time Remaining in quarter: blank
Ball Spot (yard line): any - any
Down: between 1 and 4
Yards to first down: blank
Score Difference: blank
Opponent's Formation: I (any variation)
Number of WR's in Set: Between 3 and 3

Time Remaining in quarter: 360
Ball Spot (yard line): any - any
Down: between 1 and 4
Yards to first down: blank
Score Difference: -100 to 0
Opponent's Formation: Weak I
Number of WR's in Set: Between 0 and 6


We got an Input set up for Redzone situations, but restricted to "I (any formation)" shown by the offense. But this input doesn't have a 3-4 output...

I hate to say it, but this doesn't look like a wrong AI set up. Either the cover 1 is screwed up for some reason or the AI didn't call the proper play.

(thanks for your attention)
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Yes that is single back big. Do you have a single back defense set? If not, it will pick from something based on your basic settings.
 
RAPB
offline
Link
 
AI is set this way:

AI for All Quarters (General Settings)

(Input: within our 10 + offense: goalline formation)
(Input: [any spot] + offense: goalline formation)
(Input: [any spot] + offense: weak I)
(Input: within our 10 + offense: I (any variation))
(Input: Strong I 3rd short)
(Input: Strong I 3rd long)
(Input: Strong I)
(Input: Big I)
... and then the following Input, named Single Back Big

Input is set at:

time blank
any spot - any spot
Down 1 - 4
yards blank
score blank
formation: single back big
Number of WR's in Set: between 0 and 2

I checked every single input in the AI to make sure it got a offensive formation. There's not a single input saying "Any Formation" - so there shouldn't be any input interfering).


?
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Does it match in the tester? Maybe the selector for singleback is typoed or something.
 
RAPB
offline
Link
 
To make it worse:

Defense AI tester

Enter Situation
Quarter: 4
Time Remaining: 406 seconds
Ball Spot: 9 yd line (same for 10)
Down: 2
Yards to go: 3 yards
Score: I'm leading by 36 points

Opponent Formation: Single Back Big
Number of Wide Receivers: 2


Matching Input
Input Named: Single Back Big

Possible Outputs
25% 3-4 - 2/M/S/P/C/0 (3-4 Cover 2 man)
25% 3-4 - 1/M/M/B/C/0 (3-4 Cover 1 man)
50% 4-3 - 2/M/S/P/C/0 (4-3 Cover 2 man)


(all are without blitzers)



The only thing I can think of:

"Number of Wide Receivers: 2"


Maybe it counts the additional TE as third WR?
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
No, the play def has receivers set to "2."

The only thing I can think of is that maybe there's a typo in the formation for the AI inputs causing it not to match or something. Will have to check and see though.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Hm, no...that's not it.

I just looked up the play id that got called and the defense play was:

3-4 Cover 1 Man Under no shift

Isn't that what it was supposed to be? Is it just the SS's position that's confusing?
 
RAPB
offline
Link
 
It's the FS heading for the HB like mad!

In cover 1, he should be staying deep in case something goes wrong!

(...and that's what the FS does - exept for this play!)
Last edited Sep 21, 2008 17:47:18
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
LOL I didn't really even notice that. Strange, the play definition is not set for him to do that at all. I wonder if it has less to do with the formation and more to do with the position on the field? His zone would would end up being shallower than usual since it's close to the endzone, and maybe he saw the HB as a big threat or something?

Still, with the setting he's set to on the play, he's supposed to stay back at least as deep as the deepest receiver, so I'm not sure what's up.
 
RAPB
offline
Link
 
Actually... I wouldn't have been surprised if the FS went out of bounds (as usual... that's something that happens quite a lot with safeties in the endzone).

But that really looked like cover 0 (FS covers HB) or a FS blitz.

Could it be that SA Super Vision of the FS triggered and the play was supposed to be a short HB pass?

(if so... it sure makes it worse if the Super Vision makes the defender shut down the original play to allow the QB to "check down" to a possible TD pass...)
 
bigpimpin123
offline
Link
 
Vision? lol
 
RAPB
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bigpimpin123
Vision? lol


...medium (= soft cap I + 3 Super Vision)
 
Ratphlegm
offline
Link
 
That is a very strange defense. Clearly man underneath, as for some reason the LILB starts standing on top of the ROLB to cover the 2nd TE, and it definitely looks like the FS is taking part in the man underneath coverage since he's going to triple team the HB (because you really need to triple team that guy of all people). He really doesn't look like he's blitzing since his route is so indirect (but maybe he's on evasive... really evasive).

Something we discovered in another thread a couple weeks ago is that the 0 max blitzers settings was not working. I don't know if Bort saw that thread and fixed the issue yet, but we came to the conclusion that simply setting a play to 0 max blitzers wasn't enough to ensure nobody would blitz. You have to put a 0 in the space for each defender that'll be on the field for that output to make sure they won't blitz, or else it was just using your default blitz settings (from basic tactics).

Is it possible that the FS would mistakenly read a run play? I've noticed several times when FS's read run immediately after the snap and it looks like they're blitzing (when they're set to 0% blitz), but it has always been on a run play.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ratphlegm
That is a very strange defense. Clearly man underneath, as for some reason the LILB starts standing on top of the ROLB to cover the 2nd TE, and it definitely looks like the FS is taking part in the man underneath coverage since he's going to triple team the HB (because you really need to triple team that guy of all people). He really doesn't look like he's blitzing since his route is so indirect (but maybe he's on evasive... really evasive).

Something we discovered in another thread a couple weeks ago is that the 0 max blitzers settings was not working. I don't know if Bort saw that thread and fixed the issue yet, but we came to the conclusion that simply setting a play to 0 max blitzers wasn't enough to ensure nobody would blitz. You have to put a 0 in the space for each defender that'll be on the field for that output to make sure they won't blitz, or else it was just using your default blitz settings (from basic tactics).

Is it possible that the FS would mistakenly read a run play? I've noticed several times when FS's read run immediately after the snap and it looks like they're blitzing (when they're set to 0% blitz), but it has always been on a run play.


I didn't see that thread. I will have to check that for sure. I wonder if that's causing problems here? It looks like the FS is playing the HB though.
Last edited Sep 21, 2008 22:48:36
 
Forbin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ratphlegm
Something we discovered in another thread a couple weeks ago is that the 0 max blitzers settings was not working. I don't know if Bort saw that thread and fixed the issue yet, but we came to the conclusion that simply setting a play to 0 max blitzers wasn't enough to ensure nobody would blitz. You have to put a 0 in the space for each defender that'll be on the field for that output to make sure they won't blitz, or else it was just using your default blitz settings (from basic tactics).


Off topic, but I fixed this (I think..we'll find out eventually) by setting my basic AI blitz % to 0. So the only blitzes are the ones I call. A hell of a lot easier than putting a 0 into all those fields.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.