I used to think he did - he often talks about running sims to test all the nerfs he does, etc - but based on the new advanced item store I'm starting to wonder. So far I've seen a great many of the new items through one means or another and it appears that about 90% are completely useless, with another 10% having the potential to be useful if you sit on them and horde bonus tokens for 2 seasons. What say you guys?
TtD
offline
offline
10 players, one equipment token for 8, 3 for 2. One viable high end piece of equipment, +3 Agility +1 Strong Base for a 30DT. Think it's out there but your going to have to burn through a lot of tokens to get what your after.
Mr. Moses
offline
offline
I was hoping it would save money over the normal equipment. The training needs more options. Thus far, I'm a little underwhelmed. :/
rj414
offline
offline
These items would be useful if they didnt replace existing ones - as it is it is more useful for new players than existing ones.
Mr. Moses
offline
offline
Exactly. Instead of the same 'equipment', they should be helmets, shoulder pads, etc..
Eh though I was a little unimpressed with the training updates, I kinda like it. Gives people more opportunities to hurt the growth of their player.
Mr. Moses
offline
offline
Originally posted by Mat McBriar
Eh though I was a little unimpressed with the training updates, I kinda like it. Gives people more opportunities to hurt the growth of their player.
Hehe. Touche
Eh though I was a little unimpressed with the training updates, I kinda like it. Gives people more opportunities to hurt the growth of their player.
Hehe. Touche
Victory Jones
offline
offline
Originally posted by Mat McBriar
Eh though I was a little unimpressed with the training updates, I kinda like it. Gives people more opportunities to hurt the growth of their player.
+1...
Eh though I was a little unimpressed with the training updates, I kinda like it. Gives people more opportunities to hurt the growth of their player.
+1...
Sonny Walker
offline
offline
hehehe
yeah
the best thing about them is getting stuff you can't get elsewhere - I had to think long and hard before turning my back on a skill that aid catching low passes, for instance...
still, on average even the ones I'd buy aren't really better than normal equipment - having to choose between them, I pick the advanced ones more for novelty than strategy.
I think once I can upgrade one (depending on what I get for the upgrade) they might be really useful, but spending 25 days of training to get 1 advanced item (plus 1 day for buying the item in the first place) SUCKS - I'm going to do it once just to see what it offers me
I haven't decided if I like 4 bonus tokens/10 days for +1 stat and +5 for 1 game
I think it's useful if you train low stats and then use the +1 on a high stat - otherwise regular training seems to make more sense, in addition to being cheaper, & having the seconday options as well...
yeah
the best thing about them is getting stuff you can't get elsewhere - I had to think long and hard before turning my back on a skill that aid catching low passes, for instance...
still, on average even the ones I'd buy aren't really better than normal equipment - having to choose between them, I pick the advanced ones more for novelty than strategy.
I think once I can upgrade one (depending on what I get for the upgrade) they might be really useful, but spending 25 days of training to get 1 advanced item (plus 1 day for buying the item in the first place) SUCKS - I'm going to do it once just to see what it offers me
I haven't decided if I like 4 bonus tokens/10 days for +1 stat and +5 for 1 game
I think it's useful if you train low stats and then use the +1 on a high stat - otherwise regular training seems to make more sense, in addition to being cheaper, & having the seconday options as well...
nilhaus
offline
offline
It might be worth getting the advanced equipment if anyone knew what +2% to X meant or any other of the details.
Does that mean if I have a 75% chance to catch a ball, that I now have a 77% chance (75 + 2), or a 76.5% chance (1.02 * 75). Does that factor in before penalties like a CB in your face and pass quality, or after penalties? How much of a bonus is +5 catching worth vs +2% catching?
While I don't really have a problem with him hiding the details of the sim, without some transparency there is no way to make a real decision on equipment other than just guessing and pretending you know you are right. And guessing vs. getting a guaranteed +1 skill point isn't worth it in my opinion. Especially since when you get that advanced equipment, you may as well save/waste your bonus tokens on making it better. 10 a season is a little absurd though.
It might be worth it for low level players, but for existing players it is simply too late really. By the time it is as good as the equipment we already have we will be retiring.
Does that mean if I have a 75% chance to catch a ball, that I now have a 77% chance (75 + 2), or a 76.5% chance (1.02 * 75). Does that factor in before penalties like a CB in your face and pass quality, or after penalties? How much of a bonus is +5 catching worth vs +2% catching?
While I don't really have a problem with him hiding the details of the sim, without some transparency there is no way to make a real decision on equipment other than just guessing and pretending you know you are right. And guessing vs. getting a guaranteed +1 skill point isn't worth it in my opinion. Especially since when you get that advanced equipment, you may as well save/waste your bonus tokens on making it better. 10 a season is a little absurd though.
It might be worth it for low level players, but for existing players it is simply too late really. By the time it is as good as the equipment we already have we will be retiring.
Victory Jones
offline
offline
Originally posted by rj414
These items would be useful if they didnt replace existing ones - as it is it is more useful for new players than existing ones.
exactly...
These items would be useful if they didnt replace existing ones - as it is it is more useful for new players than existing ones.
exactly...
Sonny Walker
offline
offline
you're right, nilhaus - I think advanced equipment is only any good if it offers you something you don't have access to normally
which isn't probably even attractive to most players, but it is to me
which isn't probably even attractive to most players, but it is to me
zgcreech
offline
offline
one of our DEs found a +3 agility +1 tunnelvision on his first refresh. Lucky click i guess.
Last edited Sep 27, 2008 00:39:05
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.