User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Tackling gear way too common for O-linemen
Page:
 
kurieg
offline
Link
 
New Info:
73% of gear generated for a level 1 Center had Make Tackle +2% on it.


Well, fortunately Bort made it so that every new player gets 7 Training Points, so I created 7 DTs and 7 Cs to compare equipment.
The result:
Bonus DT C
Agility 10% 5%
Avoid Fake 25% 0%
Blocking 10% 8%
confidence 5% 8%
Deflect Ball 32% 0%
Hold Block 0% 0%
Jumping 11% 3%
Make Tackle 29% 73%
Speed 5% 6%
Stamina 8% 6%
Strength 3% 6%
Tackling 10% 3%
Vision 6% 8%

Hold Block is never used for either position. All the Deflect Pass and Avoid Fake of the DT position became Make Tackle results for the C.
























I posted this in Suggestions, but I believe it's actually got to be a bug. Otherwise, Bort intends that Make a Tackle gear is 5x to 10x more likely than Hold a Block gear for Offensive linemen!

O-linemen are having as good as a 33% chance to get gear with +Make Tackle %, very small chance at +hold a block %, and virtually 0% chance to get gear with +Blocking. I believe there's a bug or error in the chance to get blocking gear, especially for O-linemen.


My defensive linemen gear seems to have some offerings of all kinds.

The breakdown:

Offensive linemen, level 26-29, 36 pieces of gear:
+Blocking - 0
+Hold Block % - 2
+Tackling - 4
+Make Tackle % - 11

Offensive Tackles seem especially bad at rolling +Make Tackle.

This is nuts.

I scrolled through about 8-9 pages of mwfinest's big list on the main forum, and this trend is definite.
1) 33% chance to get a +% to Make Tackle (especially for an OT)
2) 0% chance to get +Blocking
3) maybe 5-10% chance to get +Hold Block.


Last edited Sep 19, 2008 18:15:45
 
lazloth
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
tackling is a universal skill for all positions.

 
Robbnva
offline
Link
 
I agree 100%

in before vanilla locks thread and says not a bug.
 
Robbnva
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by lazloth
Originally posted by Bort

tackling is a universal skill for all positions.



Bort needs to have his head examined
 
cwrujosh
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by lazloth
Originally posted by Bort

tackling is a universal skill for all positions.



No it's not.
 
lrunkle911
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by lazloth
Originally posted by Bort

tackling is a universal skill for all positions.



ok, fundamentally it may be true from a skills percpective.

BUT WHY WOULD I WANT TO BUY EQUIPMENT WITH IT????

 
kurieg
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by lazloth
Originally posted by Bort

tackling is a universal skill for all positions.



This is not a thread about whether O-linemen should or should not get some +tackling/make tackle gear.

This is about whether it's a bug that +tackling/make tackle gear is FAR, FAR more common for offensive linemen than +blocking/hold a block.

I believe Bort didn't mean for it to be this way. Maybe I'm just hopeful.
 
kurieg
offline
Link
 
Fortunately, I have tracked down the issue and will be editing the original post with better info.
 
arcadecowboy
offline
Link
 
Superior Black Visor
+2 tackling

Superior Red Shirt
Make tackle chance +2%

Superior Yellow Gloves
Make tackle chance +2%


So... can my guard buy these and give them to his LB friend?



If the adv equipment store is random in what type of equipment it shows, it does seem strange that my Guard gets 3 out of 3 in Tackling. I'm not a statistician, but I'm gonna guess that the odds are against it.
 
Robbnva
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by arcadecowboy
Superior Black Visor
+2 tackling

Superior Red Shirt
Make tackle chance +2%

Superior Yellow Gloves
Make tackle chance +2%


So... can my guard buy these and give them to his LB friend?



If the adv equipment store is random in what type of equipment it shows, it does seem strange that my Guard gets 3 out of 3 in Tackling. I'm not a statistician, but I'm gonna guess that the odds are against it.


your guy can play both ways
 
kurieg
offline
Link
 
You are correct, Arcadecowboy. For offensive linemen, the equipment generator is replacing all the chances for things like Avoid Fake and Deflect Pass with Make TAckle results.
 
Greg B
offline
Link
 
I just can't even determine how tackling would be involved with an offensive lineman. I played Offensive Tackle in school and I don't remember tackling anyone. The only thing I could possibly think of that would associate tackling with an O Line player is that a defender gets by him and tackles him. That just turns out to be a penalty so its useless. I just don't get it
 
kurieg
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Greg Butler
I just can't even determine how tackling would be involved with an offensive lineman. I played Offensive Tackle in school and I don't remember tackling anyone. The only thing I could possibly think of that would associate tackling with an O Line player is that a defender gets by him and tackles him. That just turns out to be a penalty so its useless. I just don't get it


I agree with your reasoning.

I'm trying to just focus on the bugged aspect, though, as I believe there's a major problem with how the loot is generated. Even though I know Bort wants some tackling gear to show up for everyone, I don't think he meant for 73% of the gear to have it!!!
 
catspaw27
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by lazloth
Originally posted by Bort

tackling is a universal skill for all positions.



Really? The only time it would come into play for an offensive player is during a turnover. I better change gear now, because somehow the chicks don't dig blockers.

Is catching a universal skill too? Because you know there is that occasion when the QB hits the blitzing LB in the head, the ball bounces up in the air and the round mound of rebound actually makes the catch.

I am sooooo hoping my RB gets a passing +2 for when in season 14 I can call that HB pass. Man, that's going to be sweet.
Last edited Sep 19, 2008 18:23:41
 
Vagrant God
offline
Link
 
I had two options for tackling gear as well...Way too common to be a coincidence, this should be looked at or at least explained...
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.