User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Training Bug: Normal training with no secondary activity less effective than with a secondary activity
the7trumpets
offline
Link
 
In the post Bort made, as well as the description of the training system on the training page, if you train on normal with no secondary activity (go shopping or night on the town), you are supposed to get a slight training boost. What I have found is the exact opposite, training on normal WITH a secondary activity gives you a slight boost over no secondary activity.

First the results, then I will paste the supporting data.

On normal with no secondary activity, training resulted in results which were approximately 2.4% higher than the 'expected' values at the bottom right of the training page.

On normal training WITH a secondary activity, results were approximately 8% higher than the 'expected' value at the bottom right of the training page. That means it is about 5.4% more effective than training with no secondary activity.

It appears that either the 'small training bonus' is being subtracted instead of added, or the other forms of normal training are getting the training bonus instead of the 'no secondary activity' type of training.


Please, before you say I'm imagining things, here is my supporting data. I created 25 players, trained them 3 times each, recorded the results, and retired them, meaning I have 75 data points. Please do not dispute this because of a few players you happened to train a couple of times, to confirm trends like this you need decently large data sets.

Okay, so here is the raw data. My appologies for the horrible formatting, but this board doesn't support PRE or CODE tags, so there isn't anything I can do about it.

Starting at 10, normal with bonus:
Expected:
53 53 51
Observed:
54 54 53
54 54 51
54 55 52
54 54 53
54 55 53
53 53 53
55 56 53
56 53 52
54 54 51
55 54 52
Average:
54.3 54.2 52.3
Difference:
2.45% 2.26% 2.55%

Starting at 10, normal without bonus (shopping token):
Expected:
53 53 51
Observed:
58 58 56
56 57 56
58 58 54
56 58 56
57 57 54
58 57 54
57 57 55
56 58 56
58 56 54
58 57 56
Average:
57.2 57.3 55.1
Difference:
7.92% 8.11% 8.04%
Diference above 'training bonus' (training with no secondary activity)
5.53% 5.35%

Starting at 10, normal without bonus (night on town):
Expected:
53 53 51
Observed:
59 57 56
58 58 56
57 57 56
56 55 56
58 58 55
Average:
57.6 57 55.8
Difference:
8.68% 7.56% 9.41%


Last edited Sep 19, 2008 07:38:23
 
Zoblefu
offline
Link
 
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=1065292
 
RMiller517
offline
Link
 
Thread locked by moderator.
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.