I'm not surprise people are bailing. Teams should be somewhat evenly matched but that is definitely not the case. It seems there are A teams and B teams. A teams steamroll B teams no matter what tactics are involved. I can run say a weak I HB slam with a PHB into a 3-2-5 against pass rushing DTs and get a half a yard. My opponent can run the same play with a combo or elusive HB into a 4-3 with an all run stuffing DL for 7+ yards a pop while breaking multiple tackles.
I thought it was bad rolls on players but that doesn't seem to be the case. I wounder if everyone carried one human punter if it would trick the sim into evening everything out.
I'm not selling my team because it only costs my 400 FP in the end.
It really is hard to say for sure without knowing players builds, but I think there is more to it then that, not saying this isn't part of it, just I see things a little more complex then that!