Warrior General Games

I need two CB for a National Pro team. As I scrounge, I see two possibilities from my own players. One could be moved up from a low level and one I was planning on retiriing. If you could pick, which CB would you take and is the decision close at all. Not the best builds, but not terrible either considering they were made to compete in Pee Wee.

CB 1 (-111)
Attributes
Physical Attributes
Strength: 61.37
Speed: 119.39 (+38)
Agility: 85.54 (+11)
Jumping: 61.54 (+2)
Stamina: 51.54
Vision: 75.39
Confidence: 45.52

Football Skills
Blocking: 9
Catching: 40.35
Tackling: 68.37
Throwing: 8
Carrying: 27.33
Kicking: 8
Punting: 10

Special Abilities
Shutdown Corner Abilities
Swat Ball: 3
Sticky Hands: 3
Superior Vision: 3
Smooth Operator: 3
Shutdown Coverage: 5

Speedster Abilities
First Step: 4
Change Direction: 3
Return Specialist: 2
Blitz: 3
Closing Speed: 4

Additional Abilities
Jackhammer: 12
Veteran Abilities
Ball Hawk: 15
Quick: 6
Track Star: 15
Long Reach: 15
Third Down Stopper: 15

Current Bonuses/Penalties
Speed: +3.66
Agility: +1.34
Deflect ball chance: +22%
Intercept chance: +21%

CB2 (562 Days Old Decline)
Attributes
Physical Attributes
Strength: 38.49
Speed: 118.13 (+37)
Agility: 81.13 (+1)
Jumping: 76.13 (+6)
Stamina: 51.33
Vision: 78.13 (+3)
Confidence: 52.57

Football Skills
Blocking: 8
Catching: 43.33
Tackling: 52.57
Throwing: 10
Carrying: 24.49
Kicking: 10
Punting: 8

Special Abilities
Shutdown Corner Abilities
Swat Ball: 5
Sticky Hands: 5
Superior Vision: 5
Smooth Operator: 4
Shutdown Coverage: 13

Speedster Abilities
First Step: 3
Change Direction: 3
Return Specialist: 2
Blitz: 2
Closing Speed: 0

Additional Abilities
Jackhammer: 5

Veteran Abilities
Quick: 15
Clutch: 7
Long Reach: 15
Showboat: 15
Third Down Stopper: 15

Current Bonuses/Penalties
Agility: +3.61
Intercept chance: +23%