User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Epic Suggestions > Add a Revcake Trophy
Page:
 
89stepside
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by AC
WTF?

Someone smarter than me explain this post please.


I think he's saying that whether or not they have DT's is irrelevant. If not, that what he should be saying.
 
iwantateam
offline
Link
 
+1 it would help recruters find the best players.
 
AC
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by 89stepside

Edit: Meh... changing my vote to a +1. Still believe the above, but really, who cares. Certainly isn't going to make the game less enjoyable for me, so why not. Keep that in mind next time somebody suggests something that doesn't affect you. If it doesn't hurt the game, and makes someone else enjoy the game more.... vote YES!


Agreed.

 
Domers3021
offline
Link
 
This is by far the most useless stat in the game...By a long shot.
 
Domers3021
offline
Link
 
And running a close second is the pancake...
 
Tyrius
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by geekor
so basically a trophy for one position? No thanks -1


Right, because passing yards, passing TDs, FGs made, XP made and yards per punt apply to more than one position. DEs are about as likely to win revcake trophies as FBs and RQBs are to win rushing related trophies.

Revcakes are useless as a stat for the most part but you might as well reward NT/DTs since GLB rewards just about every other position. +1 Make it harder to record revcakes then hand out the trophies.
 
Daver
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by glwarriors
+1

Makes much more sense than a Pancake trophy.


Yeah because O lineman have so much to brag about in this game.... With all the stats the could look through for all these seasons...
 
Daver
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by FLGator
How many RevCakes are happening away from or after the play and have no impact on the play whatsoever? Take my Centers for example, they get RevCaked pretty regularly...but neither has given up a sack nor a hurry this season. What's the point?

(FWIW, I'm just as happy to take away the Pancake trophy...it's equally meaningless.)


I would be willing to bet your Center got a few pancakes when the play ran to the outside... Was that a meaningful pancake?
 
onemiln09
offline
Link
 
I dont like the RP or should I say frequency of it but I'll vote for anything that gives another customer a trophy for their guy.
 
tsherr
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Domers3021
This is by far the most useless stat in the game...By a long shot.


The value of the stat isn't in question. Part (for some people, most) of the fun in this game is getting stats, trying to lead in a stat category, and ultimately, getting a trophy in a stat category. Removing that fun for a specific position makes it less likely people will build that position, and that hurts the game.

T
 
Ojete
offline
Link
 
+1
 
dmet
perky
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by glwarriors
+1

Makes much more sense than a Pancake trophy.


How so? They are the same thing. Still a good idea but a questionable comment.

+1
 
osu888
offline
Link
 
+1
 
TheTaste
offline
Link
 
Why not...+1
 
McCoySoDope
offline
Link
 
No, bad idea, -1.

Nah just kidding +1 for that ^ and +1 again
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.