Warrior General Games

My level 25 guy (without EQ) has 73 carrying, 63 strength, 62 agility, 40 confidence in primaries.
Secondaries - speed, stamina, vision, blocking all in the 15-23 range.
Power Thru and Quick Cut are his favored offensive abilities.
Career rushing average = 4.8, only occasional receiving.
Which VA's should I start with and which ones for the future?

Being that you are a Power rusher, I would think Bruiser would be a good start.

Be aware that your Tactics settings must be 50 to the Power side for it to activate.

Other than that, you may look at Punishing Runner if your team uses it on a widespread with its Rushers.

Any suggestions for a third/fourth option?

yac attack if you get passed to often
short yardage monster if you pick up spin, juke, or head fake
steady grip for points in carrying

1. Bruiser
2. Short Yardage Monster
3. Quick Feet (if you pick up Spin/Juke/Head Fake (you should pick up Spin))
4. Mr. Reliable (if you get passed to and have trouble catching the ball)
5. YAC Attack (if you get passed to and don't have trouble catching the ball)
6. Steady Grip
7 Tenacious (if you don't have Spin/Juke/Head Fake and you don't get passed to)