I'd give them speed, punting, blocking, and pumpfake
jdbolick
offline
offline
Most long threads could be avoided if people just paid more attention to my posts, since I generally have the answer:
Originally posted by jdbolick
Probably a better idea than what it is now. Apparently there's a big emphasis on having all archetypes with the same number of majors, but there's no particular reason why they should. You can't replace Vision or Confidence with Strength or Agility because that would make it too appealing compared to the other choices, but what if strength became a fifth major? Then you end up with:
HB Combo
5'9" - 6'2", 200-230 Lbs
Major Carrying Confidence Speed Vision Strength (+.4)
Minor Agility Catching Stamina Jumping (+.25)
Bonus SA's - None
Penalty SA's - None
That way it's never going to be as fast as a true elusive or scat back, nor as good at breaking tackles as the power archetype, yet it truly would be a middle ground between the two.
Originally posted by jdbolick
Probably a better idea than what it is now. Apparently there's a big emphasis on having all archetypes with the same number of majors, but there's no particular reason why they should. You can't replace Vision or Confidence with Strength or Agility because that would make it too appealing compared to the other choices, but what if strength became a fifth major? Then you end up with:
HB Combo
5'9" - 6'2", 200-230 Lbs
Major Carrying Confidence Speed Vision Strength (+.4)
Minor Agility Catching Stamina Jumping (+.25)
Bonus SA's - None
Penalty SA's - None
That way it's never going to be as fast as a true elusive or scat back, nor as good at breaking tackles as the power archetype, yet it truly would be a middle ground between the two.
MRIGUY
offline
offline
I guess you can't give combo speed, carrying, and strength because that might be too much, but my above suggestion may be a good compromise.
And remember combo has no SA bonus so that sucks too.
And remember combo has no SA bonus so that sucks too.
MRIGUY
offline
offline
Originally posted by Timetoshine-Beta
I'd give them speed, punting, blocking, and pumpfake
I'd give them speed, punting, blocking, and pumpfake
TrevJo
offline
offline
Originally posted by jdbolick
Apparently there's a big emphasis on having all archetypes with the same number of majors, but there's no particular reason why they should. You can't replace Vision or Confidence with Strength or Agility because that would make it too appealing compared to the other choices, but what if strength became a fifth major? Then you end up with:
HB Combo
5'9" - 6'2", 200-230 Lbs
Major Carrying Confidence Speed Vision Strength (+.4)
Minor Agility Catching Stamina Jumping (+.25)
Bonus SA's - None
Penalty SA's - None
That way it's never going to be as fast as a true elusive or scat back, nor as good at breaking tackles as the power archetype, yet it truly would be a middle ground between the two.
+1!
Apparently there's a big emphasis on having all archetypes with the same number of majors, but there's no particular reason why they should. You can't replace Vision or Confidence with Strength or Agility because that would make it too appealing compared to the other choices, but what if strength became a fifth major? Then you end up with:
HB Combo
5'9" - 6'2", 200-230 Lbs
Major Carrying Confidence Speed Vision Strength (+.4)
Minor Agility Catching Stamina Jumping (+.25)
Bonus SA's - None
Penalty SA's - None
That way it's never going to be as fast as a true elusive or scat back, nor as good at breaking tackles as the power archetype, yet it truly would be a middle ground between the two.
+1!
jdbolick
offline
offline
Originally posted by TrevJo
+1!
Shhh. It doesn't matter if the idea is good, only if someone nice or sycophantic posts it. Quick, someone with a spotless forum record re-word my brilliant solution.
+1!
Shhh. It doesn't matter if the idea is good, only if someone nice or sycophantic posts it. Quick, someone with a spotless forum record re-word my brilliant solution.
MRIGUY
offline
offline
Originally posted by Deathblade
Originally posted by MRIGUY
speed, agility, and strength
Is this a srs post?
OK what do you want me to say? The other HB choices have 3 of the 4 main attributes....Combo has 2 and no bonus SA....Just remove it or give it 3 of the 4 main attributes....
speed, strength, and carrying?
agility, strength, and carrying?
Originally posted by MRIGUY
speed, agility, and strength
Is this a srs post?
OK what do you want me to say? The other HB choices have 3 of the 4 main attributes....Combo has 2 and no bonus SA....Just remove it or give it 3 of the 4 main attributes....
speed, strength, and carrying?
agility, strength, and carrying?
Deathblade
offline
offline
Originally posted by jdbolick
Shhh. It doesn't matter if the idea is good, only if someone nice or sycophantic posts it. Quick, someone with a spotless forum record re-word my brilliant solution.
Originally posted by Deathblade
Probably a better idea than what it is now. Apparently there's a big emphasis on having all archetypes with the same number of majors, but there's no particular reason why they should. You can't replace Vision or Confidence with Strength or Agility because that would make it too appealing compared to the other choices, but what if strength became a fifth major? Then you end up with:
HB Combo
5'9" - 6'2", 200-230 Lbs
Major Carrying Confidence Speed Vision Strength (+.4)
Minor Agility Catching Stamina Jumping (+.25)
Bonus SA's - None
Penalty SA's - None
That way it's never going to be as fast as a true elusive or scat back, nor as good at breaking tackles as the power archetype, yet it truly would be a middle ground between the two.
Shhh. It doesn't matter if the idea is good, only if someone nice or sycophantic posts it. Quick, someone with a spotless forum record re-word my brilliant solution.
Originally posted by Deathblade
Probably a better idea than what it is now. Apparently there's a big emphasis on having all archetypes with the same number of majors, but there's no particular reason why they should. You can't replace Vision or Confidence with Strength or Agility because that would make it too appealing compared to the other choices, but what if strength became a fifth major? Then you end up with:
HB Combo
5'9" - 6'2", 200-230 Lbs
Major Carrying Confidence Speed Vision Strength (+.4)
Minor Agility Catching Stamina Jumping (+.25)
Bonus SA's - None
Penalty SA's - None
That way it's never going to be as fast as a true elusive or scat back, nor as good at breaking tackles as the power archetype, yet it truly would be a middle ground between the two.
Deathblade
offline
offline
Originally posted by MRIGUY
OK what do you want me to say? The other HB choices have 3 of the 4 main attributes....Combo has 2 and no bonus SA....Just remove it or give it 3 of the 4 main attributes....
speed, strength, and carrying?
agility, strength, and carrying?
One is overpowered, one is already taken.
OK what do you want me to say? The other HB choices have 3 of the 4 main attributes....Combo has 2 and no bonus SA....Just remove it or give it 3 of the 4 main attributes....
speed, strength, and carrying?
agility, strength, and carrying?
One is overpowered, one is already taken.
RMiller517
offline
offline
Originally posted by Deathblade
Powerbacks have them.
They have Strength and Carrying >_>
speed > carrying
Powerbacks have them.
They have Strength and Carrying >_>
speed > carrying
Deathblade
offline
offline
Originally posted by RMiller517
speed > carrying
For a combo back I agree.
And a "fast powerback" is a combo back...sooooooooo......
speed > carrying
For a combo back I agree.
And a "fast powerback" is a combo back...sooooooooo......
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.
